Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jenny Homan's avatar

Okay, I’ve made some time to give this another proper look with my eye on critique. First off I’ll say, I won’t try to copy yours. Sorry I’m not that person. I wouldn’t know how to begin to critique plot or characterization or grammar and writing for anything worthwhile. I’m simply not experienced enough. But I’ll give you my opinion on what I liked and didn’t and how I think this thing could improve.

First off, it’s a pretty good hook. Not much action, but I wanted more of the story by the end. I immediately wondered about this world and how it works and why getting this job was so important to Fenstra and what it entails...

Secondly, one small criticism—I think you focus way to much on fashion. You could stand to add a detail or two about hair color or features. Specially with the beauty room setting, it would fit. Even if it isn’t important to the story, a woman notices such things. It would make her seem more real. Looking at oneself in the mirror is the perfect opportunity for that. It would also give an indication of her age, which only becomes apparent at chapter 3 (I think) and even then is ambiguous.

Since you say you’re not so great at description, I feel I should offer some suggestions—she could maybe lament the lines around her eyes, or a grey hair or two poking through, or at least give some indication of hair color or complexion.

As it is, Fenstra could be twenty or fifty here, she could have crooked teeth or warts on her nose or blue or green spikey or curly or flat hair there’s no way to tell. And it would suit the scene to add it. She could pay attention to the other woman’s look and compare herself to her at least a little, in ways other than their choice of dress. What you do say, hints at respect at least so that’s something.

Third, for all the work you’ve done worldbuilding, (and I see it—wow) this scene comes across as grey and generic. The only color I see is in the clothing. There’s not much to ground the reader in the setting. The choice of decor with sensory detail you showed in one of your replies I got somewhere, could really enhance the setting and ground the conversation, though it could do with a polish if you do decide to incorporate anything permanent.

Fourth, as I said before—I like the dialogue. It showcases the characters quite well. Between Fenstra and Juaa, it’s formal and functional and perfectly appropriate. Between Fenstra and the supervisor it’s awesome.

I get the image of a bubbly, slightly older gentleman, but again, some indication of his looks would be helpful. Maybe haircut, or build or attire. Women notice.

Lastly, I want to compliment you on your glossary links. That’s an awesome idea and they do work, but if you’ll allow me to show off a little—If I was going to do a glossary I would style each word as a heading within the glossary post so you can link to it directly instead of making the reader scroll through the whole thing to find that specific word that they are looking for.

I know, I know. That’s a WHOLE LOT of work. Especially now but maybe something to keep in mind if you ever start a new glossary for a new project. It’s just one of those user experience things, not at all important. And very much a smarty-pants young person kind of request.🫢Most people wouldn’t even notice or care. The fact that there’s a glossary at all is great, and the way you linked to it throughout is awesome. It must have been a ton of work and shows real dedication. It’s just that I know it can be done… Never mind forget I said anything. I might just delete this part of my comment.

Okay that’s it. MY version of a critique… I’m curious about your opinion on my opinion. Maybe we can do this again sometime.

Expand full comment
Jenny Homan's avatar

Interesting. I'll have to give this one some thought.

Expand full comment
23 more comments...

No posts